The Davis v. e.l.f. Cosmetics case has been voluntarily dismissed with prejudice per Entry #72, terminating all pending motions and deadlines. This means the case is permanently closed and cannot be refiled, with no further litigation obligations for any party. No immediate action is required before 9 AM as the case is fully concluded.
Updated 2026-03-30 22:21:58
Did this help?
This would cost $450 from a lawyer
Ada is free because people like you keep it running.
100% of contributions fund free legal intelligence for people who can't afford a lawyer. Lesson of the Day, PBC.
YOUR CASE FILE
Entry #70 (Aug 9): Defendant e.l.f. Cosmetics filed reply to motion for reconsideration regarding May 28, 2024 Court Order
Entry #71 (Oct 22): Plaintiffs Ariel Davis, Lacie Davis, and Taylor Davis filed Notice of Voluntary Dismissal
Entry #72 (Oct 24): Judge LaShonda A. Hunt entered minute order dismissing case with prejudice under Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(a)(1), terminating all pending motions and deadlines
All case deadlines eliminated; civil case status changed to terminated
WHAT THE OTHER SIDE DID
The 2.5-month gap between defendant's reply brief and plaintiffs' voluntary dismissal suggests either settlement negotiations or strategic reassessment by plaintiffs
Dismissal with prejudice indicates likely settlement agreement, as plaintiffs are waiving right to refile - unusually favorable outcome for defendant e.l.f. Cosmetics
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR YOUR CASE
Case resolution strongly favors defendant - voluntary dismissal with prejudice typically indicates settlement on defense-favorable terms or plaintiff recognition of weak case merits
Timeline suggests defendant's motion for reconsideration may have created pressure that led to plaintiffs' strategic retreat
Get daily updates on this case
Get all of this delivered to your inbox at 5 AM.
Free ($0/mo): Everything Ada knows — all 4 layers on the page and in email. What happened, your case file, what the other side did, what it means.
Personal ($19/mo): Everything in Free, delivered daily at 5 AM — plus deadline alerts. Ada warns you 7 days, 3 days, and 1 day before any court deadline. Never miss a filing date.
Multi ($49/mo): Everything in Personal for up to 5 cases. Perfect for small business owners, repeat litigants, or family law.
Professional ($299/mo): For legal teams and executive assistants. Unlimited cases, white-label, custom sources.